Before we know it, it will be Christmas and the end of another AWW Challenge year. It will be interesting to see whether this year’s end of year round-up is different in any ways to last year’s. Will the pandemic have wrought a major change in our reading practices? Time will tell. Meanwhile, we have November to write up, so here goes – with the usual award news at the end.

Nice November

Book coverOur November count of 31 reviews is down somewhat on both last November (46) and last month (37), and I guess I know why. With Victoria’s COVID-19 restictions easing and borders opening, we are running amok – living not reading – and that’s OK! Enjoy, everyone! Meanwhile, here are some November highlights:

  • Our most reviewed authors and books this month were Sophie Laguna, with her latest, Infinite splendours, and Pip Williams’ debut novel The dictionary of lost words (each with two reviews).
  • Our top reviewer was our Netherlands-based Nancy Elin (4 reviews) who was on a roll with Brona’s AusReading Month. As last month, several reviewers were runners-up with two reviews.
  • Eleven, or over 35%, of this month’s reviewed were tagged as Indigenous Author or Indigenous issues.

The Classics

We had two classics reviewed again this month, which of course I love. If you want to be featured here, you know what to do. The two books were Angela Thirkell’s Trooper to the Southern Cross reviewed by Bill (The Australian Legend) and Thea Astley’s An item from the late news reviewed by Nancy Elin. Strangely, I also read these two books this year (though in earlier months.)

Book reviewAngela Thirkell’s Trooper to the Southern Cross is a bit of a ring in, because Thirkell only lived in Australia for about ten years (after her marriage to an Australian solider) and all her published work was written after her return to England. However, Trooper is about Australia and Australians, and so it’s worth including here. Bill describes it as:

a fictionalised account of her post-war voyage to Australia, biting in its contempt of incompetent officers and sometimes laugh out loud funny …

Not only is it worth including here, it is also worth reading – as a summer read!

The same – that it’s a summer read – could not be said for Thea Astley’s biting An item from the late news, unless you, like me, read the same sorts of books over summer, at the beach, on holidays, as you read anytime! I enjoyed this book a lot, but Nancy, who is in fact a big fan of Astley’s did not like this one. Set in a small country town, telling the story of a man who wants to get away from the world to live in quietness and peace, this novel chronicles the brutality and narrow-mindedness that Astley so hated in small towns (though she also, it must be said, liked much about such towns too!) Nancy found it too predictable, the characters “bland, uninteresting, and unsympathetic”, and the overall theme “depressing” and without “a smidgen of joy”. But, she wouldn’t want this to put anyone off reading Astley!

Indigenous authors and issues

When the Challenge was being established, much thought was put into the way contributors might categorise their reviews, and what use we might make of them – such as for these round-ups. We wanted to be able to identify books written by Indigenous Australian authors, so that we could promote these under-represented writers and track how well we were doing so. It was also thought that we might want to identify books not written by Indigenous Australians, but that dealt in some way with Indigenous issues. Hence the two “forms”, Indigenous authors and Indigenous issues. I’m not sure the latter is needed or whether our contributors use it rigorously, but it is there, so …

Book coverOf the 11 books tagged with one or both of these “forms” this month, six are by Indigenous Australian authors: Ali Cobby Eckermann’s Ruby Moonlight (reviewed by Nancy Elin); Claire G Coleman’s Terra nullius (reviewed by Georgia Rose); Melissa Lucashenko’s Too much lip (reviewed by Veronica Strachan); Nardi Simpson’s Song of the crocodile (reviewed by Kali Napier and Mrs B); and Karen Wyld’s Where the fruit falls (reviewed by Lauren).

All of these have been reviewed in previous months, except Wyld’s novel which was reviewed this month, but that website is currently under redevelopment so I can’t share the review with you. Nardi Simpson’s Song of the crocodile is, like Wyld’s, a recent release, so I’ll focus on it instead! Kali Napier makes a fascinating observation about it when she writes that it:

reinvents the narrative structure of the genre through the lens of First Nations people. The white family saga may follow generations, usually with the repetition of patterns, mothers and daughters, etc. — which this does. But white family sagas are mostly written in a linear, chronological arc. … However, Song of the Crocodile is the first novel I have read that tells a family saga in the way that I have often heard that time is experienced by First Nations Peoples in the Dreaming — the past is always present. When ancestors die in this novel, that is not the end of their arc. They continue to interact with their descendants from the other side in the sky.

This sounds like a great read that will introduce us to more than just the “issues” it discusses. Mrs B isn’t quite so specific in her description, but she certainly conveys the import of Simpson’s style:

Nardi Simpson weaves in the power of traditional music, folklore, stories, practices, culture and language within her novel. There is also a focus on the influence and weight of elders past, who help to guide the Billymil family through the changes they face. The influence of the ancestors is a strong and commanding force of this novel, directing the story to its final destination.

Books by non-indigenous authors that were categorised as “Indigenous issues” were Alison Booth’s The philosopher’s daughters (reviewed by Ashleigh Meikle); Kate Grenville’s A room made of leaves (reviewed by Jennifer Cameron-Smith); Erin Hortle’s The octopus and I (reviewed by Sharon Hill); Mirandi Riwoe’s Stone sky cold mountain (reviewed by Brona); and Emma Viskic’s Resurrection Bay (reviewed by Sharon Hill).

Book coverAshleigh Meikle writes of late nineteenth century set The philosopher’s daughters, that

It is a book that makes you think about our history, our present and our future as a nation, issues of equality and the environment, though the latter might be a little more subtle than the representation of racism. It is also a song to the land, a special recognition of what land is, and how different people see it – and what it means to the Indigenous people of Australia.

Awards News

It’s really quite amazing how the awards keep coming right up to the end of the year.

Victorian Premier’s Literary Award (Fiction) Shortlist (3 of 4 by women)

Book coverThe shortlisted books by women are:

  • Gail Jones’ Our shadows
  • Laura Jean McKay’s The animals in that country
  • Vivian Pham’s The coconut children

McKay’s and Pham’s books have been reviewed for the challenge, though not in November. We are still waiting for a review of Gail Jones’ book.

Small Press Network Book of the Year shortlist (6 of 7 by women)

This award used to be called MUBA, or the Most Underrated Book Award. I guess we know why they have changed its name! Still, I always rather liked the cheekiness of the name. The shortlisted books by women are:

  • Joey Bui’s Lucky ticket
  • Sarah Hopkins’ The subjects
  • Mandy Ord’s When one person dies the whole world is over
  • Charmaine Papertalk Green’s Nganajungu Yagu
  • Jasmine Seymour & Leanne Mulgo Watson’s Cooee Mittigar: A story on Darug songlines
  • Cham Zhi Yi ‘s blur by the, (sic)

All but Mandy Ord’s and Cham Zhi Yi’s books have been reviewed for the challenge. Charmaine Papertalk Green’s poetry collection was reviewed in November by Nancy Elin (but this comes under the Poetry round-up.)

Barbara Jefferis Award winner

Lucy Treloar’s Wolfe Island won this award, but while it has been reviewed several times for the Challenge, it wasn’t reviewed this month.

Voss Literary Prize Shortlist (3 of 6 by women) and Winner

The shortlisted novels by women are:

  • Meg Mundell’s The trespassers
  • Carrie Tiffany’s Exploded view
  • Tara June Winch’s The yield

All of these have been reviewed for the challenge – including the winner, Tara June Winch’s The yield – but none in November.

Keep well, keep safe, and keep reading!


About Me

I am Whispering Gums and I read, review and blog about (mostly) literary fiction. It was reading Jane Austen when I was 14 years old that turned me on to reading literary fiction/classics, which is why I am here today doing this round-up! Little did Jane know what she started!

My love of Aussie literature started with Banjo Paterson’s ballads and Ethel Turner’s Seven Little Australians in my childhood. But, I didn’t really discover Australian women’s writing until the 1980s when I fell in love with Elizabeth Jolley, Thea Astley, Olga Masters, Helen Garner and Kate Grenville. Ever since then I have been included a good percentage of Australian (and other) women writers in my reading di