In this wrap-up of the “Romance, Erotica and Romantic Suspense” category for the 2014 Australian Women Writers Challenge, I’m guessing what you all want to know:
- Which books were being read and enjoyed throughout 2014?
- Who were our most popular authors?
- Which book attracted the most reviews?
- Which reviewers specialised in these genres?
Of the 1590 reviews linked to the 2014 AWW challenge, 265 of these were labelled by reviewers as “Romance, Erotica and Romantic Suspense”. This represents approximately 17% of the total.
The reviews comprised:
- 170 books
- 43 reviewers
- 115 authors
Of these authors, 10 attracted five or more reviews. These were:
- Rachael Johns (14) with reviews of Outback Blaze, Outback Ghost, Tease Me Cowboy and The Kissing Season
- Cathryn Hein (9), Rocking Horse Hill and The French Prize
- Helene Young (7), Safe Harbour
- Victoria Purman (7), Nobody But Him, Our Kind of Love and Someone Like You
- Rebecca Raisin (6), The Heart of Bali, Chocolate Dreams at the Gingerbread Cafe,The Bookshop on the Corner, Christmas at the Gingerbread Café and Christmas Wedding at the Gingerbread Cafe
- Fiona McCarthur (6), Red Sand Sunrise and The Prince Who Charmed Her.
- Kylie Scott (5), Lead, Lick and Play
- Fiona McCallum (5), Meant to Be, Nowhere Else, Saving Grace and Time Will Tell
- Juliet Madison (5), February Forever, Haunted Ever After, and The January Wish and
- Karly Lane (5), Bridie’s Choice, Gemma’s Bluff and Poppy’s Dilemma.
The title that attracted the most reviews (7) was Helene Young’s Safe Harbour. Congratulations, Helene!
Among our “Top 10” authors, half write rural romance: Rachael Johns, Cathryn Hein, Fiona McCarthur, Fiona McCallum and Karly Lane. (Note: some titles were also labelled “General Fiction” and appear in that wrap-up, so the statistics are skewed.)
Interesting, too, of our “Top 10”, four were shortlisted by the Australian Romance Readers Association (ARRA) for their 2013 “Favourite Australian Romance Author Award”: Rachael Johns, Cathryn Hein, Helene Young and Kylie Scott. The overall winner, toppling previous multi-year winner Anna Campbell, was Kylie Scott. (Details of all the ARRA awards can be found here.)
There were 12 books listed as “self-published”, although one of these, Lily Malone’s Fairway to Heaven has been picked up by Escape Publishing and will be released in 2015. Among the 12 books described as self-published are five authors who have also been traditionally published: Sarah Mayberry, Rachael Johns, Mel Teshco, Ainslie Paton and S E Gilchrist.
Now to the reviewers.
Of the 43 reviewers who reviewed in this category for 2014, most reviewed fewer than three books. By contrast, nine wrote 10 or more reviews. These were:
- Sam Still Reading (34 reviews)
- Bree (32)
- Brenda from Goodreads (32)
- Shelleyrae (23)
- Marcia from Book Muster Down Under (13)
- Helena from Love Reading Romance (12)
- Lauredhel (11)
- Lynxie/Coffee2Words (10) and
- Jess from Never Ending Bookshelf (10)
Monique and Kaetrin weren’t far behind, both reviewing another eight books each. So, in effect, eleven reviewers accounted for 72% of the total number of reviews, or 193 out of 265 reviews. (Amazing effort – thank you!)
And how did the AWW blog go?
During the year, Marg posted five round-ups of reviews in this category and I posted one (April):
As there were no roundups for October, November and December, I thought I’d mention here some of the reviews that came in towards the end of the year. In October there were 20 reviews, November had 17 and there were 22 in December. Titles reviewed included:
- Rain Dance by Karen Wood, a rural romance for ages 12+ reviewed by Shelleyrae.
- The Sunny Vale Girls by Fiona Palmer, reviewed by Sam Still Reading, another rural romance which Sam describes as “a wonderfully authentic read that celebrates family, love and history in an exceptionally well-rendered setting”.
- Untamed by Anna Cowan, a historical novel reviewed by Kate Belle: described as “a different kind of romance” with “excellent writing…which only occasionally gets lost to its own prettiness”. (Cowan also won ARRA’s “Favourite New Romance Author Award” for 2013.)
- Liesmith by Alis Franklin described by Kaetrin at Dear Author as “queer urban fantasy”.
- The Cinderella Moment by Jennifer Kloester which R L Sharpe describes in her mini review as “perfect YA contemporary for those who love romantic, fun, chick-lit style reads”.
- Seven Nights in a Rogue’s Bed by Anna Campbell, a Regency romance rated with a five-star rating from Shannon at Giraffe Days and described as “spicy, saucy, well-written historical romance”. Campbell this year won the 2013 ARRA award for “Favourite Continuing Romance Series” for her Sons of Sin series.
- And finally, from the Secret Confessions: Sydney Housewives series, Nella a “scorching” erotic novella by Cathleen Ross, reviewed by Sam Still Reading about a mature woman who likes to take control. Sam’s warning: “don’t read it during a total fire ban!”
This list of reviews reminds us that this category combines a number of subgenres, including “category”, “rural”, contemporary and historical romance, as well as romantic suspense and erotica, as well as books for both adult and younger audiences.
There were many more individual titles reviewed for the challenge in 2014. With the new database, we hope you’ll soon be able to search for them. In 2015, we aim to post more regular romance round-ups, but it’s a lot of work behind the scenes. If you’re a keen romance reader and would like to help on the AWW team, maybe you’d consider joining us?
Lastly (because I can)… While I founded the AWW challenge to help overcome gender bias in the reviewing of books by Australian women, I’m also aware of a massive bias against the romance genre. Consequently, although my writing has been more suspense-oriented in recent years, I’m very proud to announce that one of my own romance novels, Snowy River Man, was picked up last year by Escape Publishing and will be released on 22 February. (That’s next month!) You can find more about it here on Goodreads. Needless to say, I’d be thrilled if someone could review it for the challenge. (Honest reviews only, of course, but I hope you love it. It was a finalist some years ago in the Clendon Award.)
Thanks, everyone, for your continued support of AWW. Here’s to another great year with #aww2015! (And while you’re here, why not subscribe to our new-look blog?)
About me: My debut novel, Snowy River Man – a rural romance with suspense elements – will be published by Escape Publishing on 22 February 2015 under my pen-name, Lizzy Chandler. In between writing, I read and post reviews under my own name, Elizabeth Lhuede, at Devoted Eclectic. I also tweet via @elizabethlhuede, @auswomenwriters and @Lizzy_Chandler. If you’d like to request a review copy of Snowy River Man for the challenge, please let me know.
Very interesting round up for the year. Thanks so much Elizabeth for all your hard work.
You’re very welcome, Cathleen. Hope there are many more reviews of your work to come!
Thank you Elizabeth for the round-up and for the mention of Fairway To Heaven, and best of luck with Snowy River Man. I love the cover.
Thanks, Lily. And congratulations on your becoming a fellow Escapee! Just shows taking a risk with self-publishing can pay off.
Great wrap up, Elizabeth. I’m looking forward to reading Snowy River Man. 🙂 Congratulations.
Excellent wrap up! I need to improve on my stats for 2015 😉 Congrats on your book release next month – I’ll be looking out for it (and do come to ARRC this year!)
Thanks, Sam. I just had my ARRA membership approved. Next step, the conference. Let me know if you’d like me to arrange a review copy of Snowy River Man (though I have a hunch you already have automatic acceptance on Netgalley from Escape).
Great to see these results, Elizabeth, and thanks for all the work you put in organising this. I’d be happy to review Snowy River Man if you would like me to.
Thanks so much, Sandy. I was thinking of book bloggers, rather than authors, but the more the merrier. I’ll email you when I have more details.