With the challenge as it was originally conceived finishing at the end of 2021, most of our volunteer editors did their final round-ups in December. However, for my own interest if not for others, I wanted to do one final round-up that looked at the ten years of the challenge in my Literary and Classics area. So, instead of the usual yearly wrap-up, I’m doing a ten-year one. I’m sorry if you would like to see one for 2021, but this will have to do, I’m afraid. Here goes …
At the ten year mark, our reviews database now contains reviews for nearly 7,700 books which is an increase of nearly 12% on our total to the end of 2020. You can see them all at Books Reviewed for AWW Challenge link. This is an impressive resource, and we thank every one of you who linked even one review to our database. It will remain as a resource for wanting to find reviews of books by Australian women writers.
Now, my regular clarification: this Literary and Classics area is slippery. There are no universally accepted definitions for either, so throughout the challenge we have primarily relied on reviewers’ categorisation, and erred on the generous side. I have, nonetheless, tweaked this at times, mostly where there have been inconsistencies between reviewers. Moreover, please note that Literary and Classics can encompass all forms and genres, fiction and non-fiction. Some authors who appear here also have works that have not been tagged “literary”, and some have older works that fit into “classic” and newer works that don’t (such as Helen Garner whose career is long). In other words, counts here only relate to Literary and/or Classics. Overall counts for certain authors and, certainly, for our reviewers can be higher.
For these and other reasons, then, the figures in this wrap-up will be a bit rubbery, but they are good enough to give us a decent sense of what happened over the decade. This is not, after all, intended to be an academic treatise.
Ten-year Round-up: 2012-2021
So, where to start. The big number is that nearly 4,900 reviews were posted in the Literary and Classics area, over the decade, averaging just under 500 per annum. While numbers stabilised over the last few years, there was, right to the end, clear ongoing support, which I hope was appreciated by the authors and their publishers.
Most reviewed Literary books, 2012-2021
- Hannah Kent, Burial rites (41)
- Charlotte Wood, The natural way of things (32)
- Hannah Kent, The good people (23)
- Robyn Cadwallader, The anchoress; Heather Rose, The museum of modern love (22 each)
- Claire G Coleman, Terra nullius; Brooke Davis, Lost and found; Evie Wyld, All the birds singing (21 each)
Hannah Kent burst on the scene early in the challenge – in 2013 – with Burial rites. This and her next two overseas-set historical novels, The good people, and more recently, Devotion, were all very popular with our challenge participants.
While several First Nations writers featured well in the challenge, just one appears in this list, Claire G Coleman’s Terra nullius.
Some of these books also featured in major literary awards – in long and shortlists, and as winners: Charlotte Wood’s The natural way of things, Heather Rose’s The museum of modern love, Claire G Coleman’s Terra nullius and Evie Wyld’s All the birds singing.
Most reviewed Literary authors, 2012-2021
This is the sort of information I was keen to discover. Who are the authors we have most loved and reviewed over the decade? Which is not to say that this is a popularity contest. For example, authors who only started publishing late in our decade will not appear in this list. To see who garnered most attention recently, I suggest you check the annual round-ups. However, many of the authors we read have been around for a while and it’s interesting to see which ones were most read and reviewed. They are:
- Helen Garner, around 90 reviews covering many books, essays and short stories
- Kate Forsyth, around 74 reviews for a subset of her oeuvre deemed literary by our readers
- Hannah Kent and Charlotte Wood, around 72 reviews each (though by some counts Charlotte Wood had a little more.)
Some way behind these is next bunch with review numbers in the 40s: Favel Parrett, Toni Jordan, Natasha Lester and Sofie Laguna.
You might have noticed that there’s only a small overlap between this list and and the authors with the most reviewed books. This is because some of these authors have had multiple books reviewed for the challenge, without any particular one garnering significant attention.
Most reviewed First Nations authors, 2012-2021
Encouraging diverse reading was a major goal of the challenge, and much effort was put into highlighting diverse authors over the decade. Diversity was defined broadly, but in my area a significant focus was First Nations women writers. Interestingly, the challenge coincided with a burgeoning in the publication of First Nations writers, though we should recognise the pioneering role of UQP, which established the David Unaipon Award in the 1980s. UQP has done – and is still doing – an excellent job in this area. In addition, the First Nations Australia Writers Network (FNAWN) was established in 2013, very soon after this challenge commenced, with its inaugural chairperson being the late Kerry Reed-Gilbert.
Anyhow, all this is precursor to the fact that participants read many First Nations women writers over the decade – particularly novels and short stories, memoir and poetry. The writers most reviewed for the challenge were:
- Tara June Winch
- Melissa Lucashenko
- Anita Heiss
- Claire G Coleman
- Ellen van Neerven
Most reviewed Classics, 2012-2021
Now to the classics. We defined these primarily by age* rather than by “fame” or longevity, because we were keen to bring older writers and works to the fore. Participants rose the challenge, helped along by Bill (The Australian Legend) whose AWW Gen weeks over the last few Januaries significantly boosted contributions to our database.
It’s worth mentioning here too that in 2012, the Text Publishing company started its Text Classics series which, ten years later is, wonderfully, still going strong. They have significantly improved accessibility to a wide range of Aussie classics – by women and men.
Through Bill’s week and our general reading, many little-known or forgotten authors were brought to our attention, like Daisy Bates (1859-1951), Dora Birtles (1904-1992), Jean Curlewis (1898-1930), Mary Gaunt (1861-1942), Myrtle Rose White (1888-1961) and June Wright (1919-2012), to name just a very few. Better known “classics”, like Barbara Baynton, Katharine Susannah Prichard, Henry Handel Richardson, and Christina Stead, again to name a few, were also read, perhaps a little more than they had been. These writers from the past – both known and unknown to us – are the focus of the next phase of the challenge. Watch this space.
Meanwhile, here are our most read “classic” authors over the decade:
- Miles Franklin (what a surprise!)
- Thea Astley (only her older works were included in this count)
- Helen Garner (ditto, as for Astley)
- Henry Handel Richardson
- Elizabeth Harrower
As you can see, with the exception of Miles Franklin and Henry Handel Richardson, our most read “classic” authors were what Penguin might call “modern classics”.
* My rule of thumb was 25 years, but of there’s a big difference between what was 25 years old in 2012 and in 2021, so again the figures are rubbery.
Before I list “my” top reviewers please note that the figures only count their reviews for Classics and Literary. All have contributed other reviews too. These top reviewers have been pretty consistent, throughout the challenge:
- Jennifer Cameron-Smith (GoodReads): 234
- Whispering Gums: 217
- Cass Moriarty (GoodReads): 177
- Ashleigh Meikle (The Book Muse): 158
- Theresa Smith Writes: 142
Many other reviewers posted over 100 Classics/Literary reviews to the challenge. We also had several bloggers from overseas who posted reviews for us. They made a special contribution to spreading the word about Aussie women writers. Nancy Elin, in the Netherlands, was our most active non-Aussie participant, posting around 70 reviews to the challenge (in this category).
As I said at the beginning of this post, a big thanks to everyone who contributed even one review to the challenge. Every review is valuable and we have appreciated your support. But, for now, it’s farewell from this phase. I hope you have enjoyed it as much as we on the team have. I do hope you will stay subscribed to the blog, and join us as we explore some fascinating stories and writers from yesteryear.
About Whispering Gums
I read, review and blog about (mostly) literary fiction. It was reading Jane Austen when I was 14 that turned me onto literary fiction/classics. Little did Jane know what she started. My love of Aussie literature started in childhood with Banjo Paterson’s ballads and Ethel Turner’s Seven Little Australians. But, I didn’t really discover Australian women’s writing until the 1980s when I “met” and fell in love with Elizabeth Jolley, Thea Astley, Olga Masters, Helen Garner and Kate Grenville. Ever since then I have included a good percentage of Australian (and other) women writers in my reading diet.
Loved this decade long wrap up and pleased to see I’ve reviewed 3 out of 4 of the most reviewed literary authors and 3 of the 5 most reviewed literary books. The legacy of 7,700 books reviewed during this challenge is astounding and such an amazing resource, I truly hope it’s never lost to the sands of time. Thank you for generously volunteering your time and expertise over this time, I’m really going to miss the challenge.
Thanks Tracey … you were a regular contributor which we greatly appreciated. I’m glad you enjoyed this round-up.
Terrific round up, very interesting, noting those most read books and authors. Those names were popular in the Historical Fiction genre consistently over the years too. And look at me, just squeezing into the most reviews. Thanks for all you’ve done. I’m looking forward to watching the new focus from the sidelines.
Thanks Theresa. It was nice to see you made the list! Thanks again, of course, for your excellent role. I hope you enjoy our now focus. We are having fun deciding what to do and how.
Great round up and thank you for the mention. I’m still not clear though, is the site going to continue to act as an ongoing database for reviews?
I don’t think so … will ask Elizabeth to talk about the database in her welcome.
I think no, on account of the need for ongoing maintenance if reviews were still being added.
Thanks. I hadn’t really thought about maintenance.
Exactly what I was thinking Theresa. I even did more fixing while writing this post. Mixed up author names etc!
Left unmonitored, it could cause issues down the track with the blog. I know the database has always been the most ‘buggy’ part of the site.
I used to be a computer guy, working with databases, but pre-internet unfortunately. I still hope we can come up with a solution, and maybe even one that suits both our paths. It wouldn’t be hard to eliminate the free-for-all we have now with author (and publisher) names. We might even come up with a definition for Classic.
The thing is Bill, that people will just not be focused on adding to the database without the challenge operating?
I had a definition of classic – pretty much anything more than about 25/30 years old. That let me bring attention to a wide range of older works! But of course, what was 25/30 years old in 2012 is different to 25/30 years old in 2021!
We talked about the author and publisher issue with our database volunteer a few times, but in the end, we didn’t give it the focus it needed. I think it was a bit tricky given the structure of the database. We had very few lookup tables. I think that would have demanded some big lookup tables or a relational database? This is a hosted site, so we’ve had to do our own upgrading, maintenance etc, which is a lot for a volunteer team, particularly given the complexity of this site.
Great round up!
Thanks Ashleigh … and thanks for all your hard work and contributions over the years. You’ve been a real stalwart.
I feel privileged to be named amongst such a terrific pool of reviewers. I have enjoyed my time with this challenge and will continue to read Australian authors. Such a terrific achievement over the last decade! Thank you to everyone who has been a part of it, and has significantly extended my life by adding ‘must read books’ to the list. extended my life? Well, I have to live long enough to read all of these books, don’t I?
Haha. I can’t think of a better reason for living longer Jennifer! Thanks so much for your support and enthusiasm for the challenge.